Home / Insights / Buying and reselling: when an interior designer becomes the seller
Insights for interior designers
Buying and reselling: when an interior designer becomes the seller
Most interior design claims involve a product: a sofa, a stone floor, a run of joinery. Whether you specified it, ordered it for the client or sold it yourself decides what you owe, and which part of the claim a PI policy may answer.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Why procurement changes the claim
A designer who only designs answers for advice: the layout, the specification, the schedule. Once you buy a sofa, a light fitting or a run of joinery and invoice it to your client, you have a second relationship with them. You are the seller and they are the buyer.
The BIID Code reflects this. It defines a client as the person or organisation to whom the designer has agreed to supply “goods and/or services” (BIID, Code of Conduct). A complaint about a failed product can therefore carry two allegations: that the specification was wrong, which is a professional matter, and that the goods were defective, which is a trading one. PI is written for the first.
Specify, order as agent, or buy and resell
Studios procure in three ways, often on the same project. Each can be a different legal position.
| Position | Who contracts with the supplier | What you answer for | The PI question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Specify only | The client, who buys from the supplier | The specification, with reasonable care and skill | The core of what PI is for |
| Order as the client’s disclosed agent | Usually the client, where the supplier knows you act for a named client | The specification, and placing the order accurately | Usually a professional service. Check that procurement is in your business description |
| Buy and resell | You. The client’s contract for the goods is with you | The quality, fitness and description of the goods, as well as the specification | Many wordings exclude the sale or supply of goods, and your mark up is not insured |
In Alebrahim v BM Design London the court worked through an interior designer’s estimates, orders and percentage fee item by item, and the designer’s written terms decided what it owed (National Archives, [2020] EWHC 3393 (TCC)). The practical point for a studio is to write down which position it takes.
What the law expects of a seller
If your client is a consumer, every contract to supply goods includes a term that they are of satisfactory quality, and quality includes durability (Consumer Rights Act 2015, section 9). If the client told you what the goods were for, such as a sofa for a house with dogs, they must be reasonably fit for that purpose, unless the client did not rely on your skill or judgment (section 10). A contract term cannot take these rights away (section 31).
The remedies are a seller’s too: rejection, repair or replacement, or a price reduction. Goods that fail within six months of delivery are usually taken to have been faulty on the day they arrived (section 19). The goods stay at your risk until the consumer has physical possession (section 29).
A hotel or restaurant operator is a business buyer, and the Sale of Goods Act implies similar terms of satisfactory quality and fitness for purpose (Sale of Goods Act 1979, section 14). Your terms can limit them only so far as the limit is reasonable (Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977, section 6).
These duties are about the goods, not about how careful you were.
How PI wordings usually treat supply
The answer depends on your wording. We read these points first.
- The supply exclusion. Many design wordings exclude claims arising from the manufacture, sale, supply, installation or repair of any product, by you or your sub-contractors.
- The write back. Some restore cover where the claim arises from negligent design or specification. Whether yours does can decide a claim about goods you resold.
- Price, refunds and mark up. A PI policy does not usually insure the price of the goods, a refund, or your margin on them.
- The business description. Procurement in your own name should be described on the proposal, with its annual value. Fair presentation explained
- Rights against the supplier. Insurers take over your rights against the workshop or importer. Many wordings exclude claims where you have agreed to restrict those rights, so a supplier’s cap on its liability matters.
- Injury and breakage. Injury caused by goods you supplied is usually a products liability matter, and breakage on the road is for goods in transit cover. The other covers we arrange
Deposits, discounts and client money
Procurement puts client money and supplier discounts through your books, and both codes have rules. SBID members must hold client money in a designated client money account, keep records of every dealing, and carry PI appropriate to the client money they hold each year. They may accept profits from third parties only where the client has agreed in advance (SBID, Code of Conduct, clauses 3.3 and 8).
BIID members must record and account for all money held for a client, spend it only on the client’s written instructions, and should have procedures to avoid financial scams. They must not accept payments or benefits that could impair their impartiality (BIID, Code of Conduct, sections 2 and 5).
We ask how deposits are held, whose name is on each order and how trade discounts are disclosed.
What to settle before the first order
- Decide which of the three positions you take, and say so in your appointment.
- If you order as agent, put the client’s name on the order and ask the supplier to invoice the client, or record the agency in writing with both.
- If you resell, read the supplier’s terms before you accept them, and keep your rights against the supplier intact.
- Tell us the annual value of goods you expect to handle before you start, not at the next renewal.
- When a complaint arrives, send it to us before you offer to repair, replace or refund. We would put both allegations to insurers and ask them to confirm which they accept.
Starting to buy in your own name?
Tell us before the first order, and we will check how your wording treats supply and present the activity to insurers.
Related: PI for interior designers · Other covers · The clause guide