Home / Insights / Cost plan claims: when tenders come in over your estimate
Insights for quantity surveyors
Cost plan claims: when tenders come in over your estimate
An estimate becomes a claim when someone commits money on it. For a quantity surveyor the argument is rarely about arithmetic alone. It is about what the figure was for, who could rely on it and what you said about its limits.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
How an estimate becomes a claim
A cost plan is a prediction, made at a stated design stage on the information then available. It becomes a claim when someone commits money on it and the figure proves wrong. The usual pattern is simple. Your stage 3 cost plan supports a funding decision. Tenders come back well above it. The lender withdraws, or the client carries on and overspends.
The letter that follows may claim wasted fees, finance costs, lost profit or the whole overspend. A gap between estimate and tender does not, by itself, show negligence. The question is whether a reasonably competent quantity surveyor could have given that figure on that information, and what you told the client about how far to trust it.
The four questions these claims turn on
Cost plan claims tend to be argued in the same order, and each question has its own evidence.
| Question | What is argued | What the file needs to show |
|---|---|---|
| What was the estimate for? | The Supreme Court has said that the scope of a professional adviser’s duty is governed by the purpose of the duty, judged objectively by the reason the advice was given (Manchester Building Society v Grant Thornton [2021] UKSC 20). | The appointment and brief: was the figure for design development, a budget approval or a funding decision? |
| Who could rely on it? | The client under the appointment. A lender or investor usually only if it holds a reliance letter, a warranty or a direct assurance from you. | The reliance wording on the report. RICS recommends limiting reliance and capping liability (RICS, Risk, liability and insurance). |
| Was it wrong, or overtaken? | A measurement or rate error is one thing. Design changes, client additions and market movement after the base date are another. | A line by line reconciliation of estimate to tender. |
| What would have happened anyway? | The client has to show what it would have done with a correct figure: redesign, phase the work or stop. The loss is not automatically the gap. | Minutes and emails showing what the client knew and chose. |
A decided case: the warning that was never given
In Plymouth & South West Co-operative Society v Architecture, Structure & Management a retailer redeveloping its Plymouth store had a cost ceiling of about £5 million. Its consultant, providing design and cost services, gave a budget of £5.65 million and the work went out on a two stage tender. The judge accepted that 87% of the contract sum was made up of provisional and prime cost sums ([2006] EWHC 5 (TCC)).
The court found the consultant in breach of duty. The design and phasing were, in the judge’s words, “insufficiently advanced to enable a contract to be entered into at that time”. The client should have been advised to start one part of the works and postpone the rest until the design was complete. The judge accepted that the client would have taken that advice, and found no contributory negligence on its part.
The case was not about arithmetic. A cost plan that says plainly how provisional it is, and what should happen before the client relies on it, answers that allegation before it is made.
What the policy does with each part
- Notification. Tenders far above the cost plan can be a circumstance long before any letter of claim. Notified in time, later claims can attach to that policy year.
- Contractual liability. An appointment that promises the budget will be met goes beyond reasonable skill and care. Many wordings exclude that extra liability unless insurers approved the terms.
- Reliance letters and warranties. Cover usually follows a warranty that gives the funder no more than your client has. Check the assignment limits in your wording before you sign a funder’s own form.
- Fees. A client may withhold your fee and counterclaim for negligent cost advice. The counterclaim is a PI matter. Recovering the fee is not.
- Series of claims. One rate library or cost model used across several phases or projects could produce one claim or many. The aggregation words decide how many limits and excesses apply.
What to state on every estimate
RICS’s cost prediction standard sets mandatory requirements for members producing a cost prediction report (RICS, Cost prediction), and NRM 1 gives the order of cost estimating and cost planning (RICS, New Rules of Measurement). Following them, and saying so, is useful evidence. The page that states the basis of the estimate usually becomes the defence.
- The design stage, and the drawings, specifications and surveys the figure is based on.
- The base date, and whether inflation to tender and to completion is included.
- The exclusions, stated in full.
- The risk allowances, and what each is for.
- Who may rely on the figure, and for what purpose.
- A plain warning where the design is too provisional for the decision the client is about to take.
How long an estimate can come back, and what we would do
Contract claims can be brought for six years, or twelve where the appointment is a deed. A negligence claim for damage discovered late may be brought within three years of the date of knowledge, subject to a fifteen year long stop (Limitation Act 1980, section 5, section 8, section 14A and section 14B). PI is written on a claims made basis, so the policy in force when the claim is made responds. Past work needs a retroactive date that reaches it, and a practice that stops needs run off cover.
Faced with a typical cost plan claim, our strategy would be to notify insurers at the first sign of trouble, establish who is entitled to claim, and have the estimate reconciled to the tender before anyone debates the market. The aim is a claim confined to the loss a real error caused.
Tenders back over the cost plan?
Send us the appointment and the cost plan before you reply to anyone, and we will help you notify insurers properly.
Related: PI for quantity surveyors · Claims support · The clause guide