We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / URS v BDW: thirty years of liability for structural engineers’ residential work

Insights for engineers

URS v BDW: thirty years of liability for structural engineers’ residential work

In May 2025 the Supreme Court decided a claim by a housebuilder against its structural engineers over defects in blocks completed years earlier. Every structural practice with residential work in its past should know what was decided, and check its cover against it.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

What happened in URS v BDW

URS provided structural design for residential developments built by BDW, a developer. In late 2019 BDW found design defects in two of them. By then it no longer owned the buildings. No owner or occupier had made a claim against it, and any claim they might have brought under the Defective Premises Act would at that time have been out of time.

BDW carried out repairs anyway, in 2020 and 2021, saying the defects were dangerous. It sued URS in negligence to recover the cost. The case went to the Supreme Court on assumed facts, so URS’s negligence was assumed for the argument, not found. On 21 May 2025 seven justices dismissed URS’s appeal on every ground ([2025] UKSC 21).

The four points the Supreme Court decided

The four questions in URS v BDW and the Supreme Court’s answers
The questionThe answer
Are repair costs irrecoverable because the developer chose to do the work?No. There is no rule of law that repair costs incurred voluntarily fall outside the engineer’s duty or are too remote. Causation and mitigation are questions of fact for trial.
Does the 30 year period reach beyond claims brought under the Defective Premises Act itself?Yes. The retrospective period can also apply to negligence and contribution claims that depend on a liability under that Act. It changes the legal position, not the historical facts.
Is the Defective Premises Act duty owed to a developer?Yes. It is owed to any person to whose order a dwelling is built, including a developer. A developer can both owe the duty and be owed it.
Can a developer claim contribution when nobody has sued it?Yes. The right arises once it has paid, or been ordered or agreed to pay, compensation for the damage. Carrying out remedial works counts as payment in kind.

The time limits now in play

  • New dwellings. Work must be done in a professional manner so the dwelling is fit for habitation (Defective Premises Act 1972, section 1). Claims can be brought for 15 years from completion, or 30 years where the right accrued before 28 June 2022 (Building Safety Act 2022, section 135). A block completed in 2000 can be claimed against until 2030.
  • Existing buildings. Work on a building that contains a dwelling now carries its own duty, with a 15 year period (section 2A).
  • The exceptions. The longer period does not reopen claims settled or finally decided before 28 June 2022, and a court must dismiss a revived claim where that is needed to avoid a breach of the defendant’s Convention rights.
  • Contribution. Two years from the judgment, award, payment or agreement to pay (Limitation Act 1980, section 10).
  • Negligence. Claims for damage discovered late face an overriding limit of 15 years from the negligent act (section 14B).

Who may now bring the claim

The claimant on a past residential project is no longer only the homeowner. It may be the developer that has repaired its own former sites, with or without a claim against it. It may be another member of the design team, or the contractor, seeking contribution after paying. The letter often goes to the whole team at once.

The route can also run sideways. The High Court can make one company’s liability under the Defective Premises Act, or for a fire or structural safety risk, the liability of its associated companies where that is just and equitable (Building Safety Act 2022, section 130). And note the subject matter. URS v BDW was about structural design, not cladding. This is not an exposure that belongs only to façade and fire engineers.

What to check in your cover

The judgment is about liability, not insurance. How any policy responds depends on its own wording. These are the points we would read against a practice’s residential history.

  • Retroactive date. Does it reach back to your earliest residential project, and has it been carried across every change of insurer?
  • Who is insured. Are predecessor practices, merged firms and earlier trading names covered for their past work?
  • Fire safety and cladding terms. How wide are the trigger words, and could they reach a structural allegation on a residential block? Fire safety exclusions
  • Limit basis and aggregation. One design repeated across several blocks may be treated as one claim with one limit.
  • Notification. A developer’s letter to the design team, or a request to inspect an old project, may be a claim or a circumstance.
  • Run off. Six years after closure may be too short for residential work. Run off cover explained

What we would do with a practice now

  1. List your residential projects for the past 30 years: role, client, completion date and the entity that did the work.
  2. Find the files. The appointment, scope of services, calculations and drawing issue records show what you designed and what belonged to others.
  3. Read the schedule, retroactive date and endorsements against that list, and tell us where they do not meet.
  4. Give insurers the residential history at renewal in a form they can use, not a one line answer.
  5. Send us any letter, inspection request or enquiry about a past residential project the day it arrives, whatever your view of your role.
  6. Plan retirement or closure around 15 years, not six.

Residential work in your past?

Send us your schedule, endorsements and project list and we will tell you where the cover reaches and where it does not.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for engineers

Related: PI for engineers · Fire safety exclusions · Run off cover