We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / JCT clauses 6.15 and 6.16: what your building contract asks of your PI

Insights for design and build contractors

JCT clauses 6.15 and 6.16: what your building contract asks of your PI

No regulator tells a contractor how much PI to hold. The building contract does, and the promise you sign there can be wider than the policy you hold. This is how the JCT clauses work, how they are amended and what to check before you sign.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

Why the contract matters more than any rule

Architects, engineers and surveyors have a professional body that sets minimum PI terms. Contractors have none. Your requirement is whatever the employer writes into the building contract, the tender conditions and the collateral warranties, and it changes from job to job.

That makes the PI clause a promise you make, not a rule you follow. If the policy you hold does not match what you promised, the gap is a breach of contract, and a broken promise to insure is not usually the kind of liability a PI policy is written to pay. The time to find the gap is before signature.

What clauses 6.15 and 6.16 say in the 2024 edition

The JCT Design and Build Contract 2024 deals with PI in two clauses, headed “Obligation to insure” and “Increased cost and non-availability” (JCT DB 2024, contents). The detail sits in the Contract Particulars, which the employer completes.

JCT DB 2024 PI provisions and what to check in each
PointWhat the 2024 form providesWhat to check
Level of coverThe contractor holds PI at the level entered in the Contract ParticularsThat the figure and its basis match your schedule, for this project and every other one you have signed
Sub-limitsSpace to record sub-limits within the overall level. The 2016 edition allowed for one only, for pollution and contamination (Ashfords, JCT DB 2024 guide)That every sub-limit on your policy is written in, including fire safety
ExclusionsSpace to set out specific exclusions from the policy (Browne Jacobson, JCT 2024 changes)That the employer has seen your fire safety and cladding terms in writing
AvailabilityThe duty applies so long as cover is available at commercially reasonable rates and, new in 2024, on reasonable terms (Mills & Reeve, JCT DB 2024 insurance)That an amendment has not deleted these words
If cover is lostClause 6.16: the contractor notifies the employer so that both can discuss how to protect their positionsWho in your business would give that notice, and when

Why the 2024 changes matter

The 2024 Design and Build Contract was published in April 2024. Its PI changes are small in words and large in effect. Browne Jacobson link them to the fire related exclusions that most PI policies now carry. The older form tested availability by rates alone, so a contractor offered cover at a reasonable rate, but with a fire safety exclusion, may have had less to rely on. Adding “terms” to the test, and giving the parties a place to record sub-limits and exclusions, lets the contract describe the policy you really hold.

The protection runs one way. Mills & Reeve point out that if the market later softens and a sub-limit falls away, the employer gets no matching benefit. Expect employers’ solicitors to redraft with that in mind.

How the clause is amended, and where contractors get caught

  • The availability words are deleted. The promise then becomes absolute: you must hold the cover whatever the market offers. That is a promise about something you do not control.
  • The basis is changed. A contract that asks for a limit “for each and every claim” may not be met by a policy with an aggregate limit, or by one that is aggregate for fire safety only.
  • Nothing is entered for exclusions. If your policy excludes fire safety and the contract is silent, the employer may say it was promised full cover.
  • The period is long. A duty to maintain cover for, say, twelve years after practical completion is met one annual renewal at a time. Each renewal can bring new terms.
  • The promise is repeated. Collateral warranties and third party rights schedules often restate the PI obligation to funders, purchasers and tenants, sometimes without the availability words.
  • It is passed down unchanged. Specialist subcontractors are asked for the main contract level on a package a fraction of its size.

None of these is unusual. Each can usually be negotiated if it is raised at tender.

NEC4 and public sector tenders

NEC4 works differently. The core clauses of the Engineering and Construction Contract do not require the contractor to insure against negligent design. Where secondary option X15 is chosen, clause X15.5 requires a PI policy, and it is the one contractor’s insurance that must continue after the defects certificate. NEC’s own guidance adds that cover for a fitness for purpose standard is unlikely to be available (NEC, insurance guidance). On an NEC job, check the contract data and whether X15 is in or out before anything else.

On public contracts, section 22 of the Procurement Act 2023 requires any condition of participation to be proportionate to the nature, complexity and cost of the contract, and an authority may not require insurance to be in place before the contract is awarded (Procurement Act 2023, section 22). A tender that asks for a limit you do not yet hold is not automatically out of reach. Ask us what can be confirmed, and when.

Six checks before you sign

  1. Read the PI clause in the schedule of amendments, not the printed form. If it has been changed, send it to us for a contract review.
  2. Compare the level, the basis and the period in the Contract Particulars with your schedule.
  3. Write your sub-limits and exclusions into the Contract Particulars, in the policy’s own words.
  4. Keep the commercially reasonable rates and terms wording, and the clause 6.16 notice route.
  5. Check each warranty and third party rights schedule for a PI promise wider than the building contract’s.
  6. Check the PI you ask of your consultants and design subcontractors against what you have promised upward.

Asked to sign a PI clause?

Send us the amendments and the Contract Particulars before you commit, and we will tell you where they part company with your policy.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for design and build contractors

Related: PI for design and build contractors · Contract reviews · Fire safety exclusions