Home / Insights / Does your duty to review a design end when it is built?
Insights for designers
Does your duty to review a design end when it is built?
A design is not always finished when the drawings are issued. The courts say when a designer must look at it again, and the answer turns on your appointment, the warning signs and the date the clock starts.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
Where the duty to review comes from
The courts trace the idea to a remark by Sachs LJ in Brickfield Properties v Newton [1971]. The modern rules come from two cases about architects who designed a scheme and then oversaw its construction.
In New Islington & Hackney Housing Association v Pollard Thomas & Edwards [2001], Dyson J said the starting point is always the appointment. A designer who also supervises or inspects the work will generally have to review the design until it is built in, and some cases run that to practical completion. Ramsey J applied the same duty in Oxford Architects Partnership v Cheltenham Ladies College [2006].
In 2023 Eyre J drew the cases together in a contractor’s claim against its structural and services engineer, Lendlease v Aecom (Lendlease, [158] to [168]).
A good reason, judged by a competent professional
The duty is not an order to keep checking everything. Dyson J said a designer need not review a finished part of the design without good reason, judged by what a reasonably competent professional would have done.
His examples: the building shows signs of distress before completion; an article shows a specified material is not fit for its purpose; or the designer learns the design is dangerous. Then the design must be reviewed and, if needed, the contractor instructed to put it right (Lendlease, [161] and [162]). Everyday versions might be a failed test, a product warning, a contractor’s query exposing a clash, or cracking seen on a site visit.
What your appointment decides
Everything turns on the contract. Eyre J’s summary gives a rough map (Lendlease, [164], [168] to [172]).
| Your role | The likely position |
|---|---|
| Design only, issued to a contractor to build | Unlikely to be read as a duty to review the design after you have supplied it. |
| Design plus inspection, oversight or contract administration | A duty to review, when there is good reason, up to the point the design is built in. The contract may carry it on to practical completion. |
| Review and coordination of other designers | Limited. In the 2023 case the engineer had no duty to oversee others’ work, or to review it and give unasked advice on its compliance. |
| After practical completion | Only if the contract says so, and even then only when a good reason arises. |
Wording matters. Aecom’s appointment said a duty to report unsuitable materials created no extra duty to check others’ work (Lendlease, [40]). Look for “keep under review”, “warn” or “until the final certificate” in your own appointments, and see the clause guide.
Each missed review is a separate claim with its own clock
Ramsey J held that a failure to review is a different cause of action from the original design error, so the two accrue on different dates. Eyre J agreed: each failure accrues when it happens (Lendlease, [166], [221]). In negligence, a design claim usually accrues when the faulty design is built in, as Coulson LJ explained in Cameron Taylor Consulting v BDW Trading [2022]. He added that the old idea of a “duty to warn” after completion has fallen out of favour (Lendlease, [167], [222]).
A contract claim usually has six years from the breach, or twelve if the appointment is a deed (Limitation Act 1980, section 5 and section 8). In Oxford Architects, a clause allowing six years from practical completion did not stop the architects relying on the earlier statutory deadline; clear language is needed to remove that defence (Lendlease, [115] to [119]). Lendlease’s claims were out of time (Lendlease, [225]).
Homes differ. Defective Premises Act claims run for 30 years where the right arose before 28 June 2022 (Building Safety Act 2022, section 135), a period the Supreme Court applied to related claims in URS v BDW. See the 30 year period.
How the duty meets a claims made policy
PI is written on a claims made basis. The policy that responds is the one in force when a claim is first made, or when you first notify circumstances that could lead to one. So the warning sign that obliges you to review a design may also be a circumstance your policy expects you to report.
Policies set out how and when to notify, and late notice can cause problems. Whether redesign costs before any claim are covered depends on the wording, so check before relying on it. A review duty can run to practical completion, and housing claims for decades after, so keep cover in place when you stop practising (see run off cover).
What to do now
- Read each appointment for review, warning and checking duties, and for how long they last.
- Keep a note of the site services you actually provide. Inspection and contract administration widen the duty.
- When a warning sign appears, record it, review the design and put your advice in writing.
- Tell us the same day if it could lead to a claim. We notify your insurer for you (claims support).
- Send us any appointment with a continuing duty to warn or an extended time limit before you sign (contract reviews).
This applies to architects, engineers, principal designers and design and build contractors alike.
Asked to keep a design under review?
Send us the appointment before you sign. We read it against your PI wording and tell you where the review duty and the time limits sit.
Related: PI for architects · Run off cover · Contract reviews