We would like to set optional cookies to understand how the site is used. Essential cookies keep forms working. Cookie policy.

Home / Insights / When a fire follows your assessment: how the claim is argued and insured

Insights for fire consultants

When a fire follows your assessment: how the claim is argued and insured

Most claims against fire risk assessors start the same way: something goes wrong in a building, and someone holds up your report. What you agreed to inspect, and what the report says it did not cover, usually decide the argument. Your policy treats each part of the claim differently.

Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.

How the claim reaches you

Under the Fire Safety Order the responsible person must make a suitable and sufficient assessment of the fire risks (Fire Safety Order, article 9). Most appoint a consultancy to help. Since 1 October 2023 the assessment must be recorded in full, with the name of anyone engaged to help make it (GOV.UK, section 156 guide). Your name is on it.

The Order itself generally gives no right to sue in civil proceedings, apart from an employee’s claim against an employer (article 39). Claims against assessors are therefore usually put in contract and negligence. They tend to arrive in three ways:

  • From the client who appointed you, after a fire or after another firm’s survey finds what yours did not.
  • From solicitors for the building’s property insurers, who have paid for the damage and want to recover it.
  • From the fire and rescue authority after an audit, saying the assessment was not suitable and sufficient. The client’s own claim often follows.

Four allegations, and what each one turns on

The usual allegations in a fire risk assessment claim
The allegationWhat it turns onWhat helps you
“You should have seen it”Whether the defect, often compartmentation, fire stopping or doors, was visible within the kind of assessment agreed.The proposal, the stated limitations, dated photographs and a note of what could not be accessed.
“You should have told us to look further”Whether the report recommended an intrusive survey or a specialist where something could not be seen.A clear recommendation with a priority, and evidence that the client received it.
“The walls and doors were in scope”For buildings with two or more homes, the Order covers the structure, external walls and flat entrance doors (Fire Safety Act 2021, section 1). A report silent on them invites the question.A statement of what you considered and, where needed, a recommendation for an appraisal under PAS 9980.
“The assessor was not competent for this building”Whether the assessor’s level matched the building. BS 8674:2025 sets three levels of competence, matched to complexity (BSI).A record of who assessed, their level and registration, and who validated the report.

Why the scope and the limitations carry so much weight

A fire risk assessment is an opinion on what could be seen, on the day, within the inspection the client agreed to buy. It is not a guarantee that the building is safe. That distinction only protects you if your documents make it.

Take a typical case. A consultancy makes a non-invasive assessment of the common parts of a converted block. A fire later spreads through voids nobody opened. The scope may be a good answer. It is a weaker one if:

  • the proposal promised a “full” or “comprehensive” assessment, and the limitations appear only at the back of the report;
  • the template marks areas as satisfactory when they were not accessed;
  • the report notes that something could not be inspected but recommends nothing further;
  • the action plan gives no priority or timescale.

Standards move too. For housing, BS 9792:2025 has replaced PAS 79-2 (BSI). A proposal that still cites a superseded document hands the other side an easy first point.

What the policy does with each part of the claim

One letter usually contains several demands. A PI policy does not treat them alike, and the answer depends on the wording.

  • Damages. Repair, remediation and loss of use are what the civil liability cover is for. The first question is how the fire safety endorsement treats assessment work, and what limit applies. How fire safety exclusions differ
  • Defence costs. The printed wording may pay these in addition to the limit. Where fire safety work has its own lower limit, costs are often inside it.
  • The authority’s investigation. Failing to comply with the Order, where that places people at risk of death or serious injury, is an offence. On indictment it carries a fine, up to two years’ imprisonment, or both, and a person whose act or default caused the offence can be charged (article 32). Many wordings fund the defence to a sub-limit, but only with insurers’ prior consent. Fines are not insured.
  • Your fee. A demand to refund the fee, or redo the work free of charge, is not a claim for loss, and wordings often treat it differently. Offering either without insurers’ consent can read as an admission.
  • The other buildings. If the criticism goes to your method, every building assessed that way may be a circumstance to notify now.

What to do when the letter arrives

  1. Tell us the same day, and do no more than acknowledge the letter. PI wordings bar admissions, and spending on a defence, without insurers’ written consent.
  2. Do not write back to explain the scope yourself. That point is better made once, by solicitors insurers have appointed.
  3. Gather the proposal, the report and photographs, site notes, and any email in which the client declined a further survey.
  4. List the other buildings assessed for that client on the same template, so the notification can name those where there is a specific reason to expect a claim.
  5. If the fire and rescue authority writes, or invites anyone to an interview, treat it as notifiable. Get insurers’ consent before instructing solicitors or giving an account.

Five habits that make an assessment defensible

  • Describe the inspection in the same words in the proposal, the report and the invoice.
  • Record what you could not access, and say what should happen because of it.
  • Say what you considered about external walls and flat entrance doors, and recommend a specialist appraisal where one is needed.
  • Record the assessor’s level and registration, and who validated the report.
  • Keep proof that the client received the report and the action plan.

These are also the controls insurers ask about, and we set them out in your presentation. Fair presentation explained

Had a letter about an assessment?

Send it to us before you reply, and we will help you notify it properly and protect the other buildings you assessed.

Speak to a PI specialistPI for fire consultants

Related: PI for fire consultants · Claims support · Fire safety exclusions compared