Home / Insights / Failure to coordinate: the claim that defines a Principal Designer’s PI
Insights for principal designers
Failure to coordinate: the claim that defines a Principal Designer’s PI
A Principal Designer rarely draws the detail that fails. The claim is that nobody made the designs fit together for compliance. Here is how that claim arises, how it is argued, and what a PI policy does with each part.
Guidance only. Cover depends on your own policy wording; speak to us about your position.
How a coordination claim arises
The Building Regulations Principal Designer does not have to design anything. The role is to plan, manage and monitor the design work, and to coordinate it so that all reasonable steps are taken for the design to comply (Building Regulations 2010, regulation 11M). When a compliance failure comes to light, the client looks first at the firm whose job was to hold the design together.
The trigger is usually one of three events:
- A rejected application. On a higher-risk building no work may start until the regulator approves the building control application (GOV.UK, building control approval for higher-risk buildings). A rejection stops the programme while finance costs run.
- A refused completion certificate. Building control finds non-compliant work late, when it is expensive to change.
- A defect found years later. Each designer says the gap between its work and the next firm’s was the Principal Designer’s to close.
In each case your fee was small and the loss is not.
What the duty is, and what it is not
The claim is usually written as if you had promised a compliant building. The regulations ask for less.
You must take all reasonable steps to ensure that designers cooperate, that their work is coordinated so that the design would comply if built, and that they meet their own duties. You must liaise with the principal contractor and have regard to its comments on compliance (regulation 11M). Government guidance says a Principal Designer is not expected to be an expert in every design specialism, but is expected to know enough about the building regulations to assess whether a design will comply (GOV.UK, dutyholder guidance).
Each designer keeps its own duty to take all reasonable steps to design for compliance. A designer producing only part of the design must consider the related design work and report any compliance concern to you (regulation 11K).
So the question in a claim is rarely “was the design wrong?” It is “what would a competent Principal Designer have asked for, checked and chased, and did you?”
One claim, several parts: how PI treats each
A letter of claim mixes several things, and a PI wording may treat each one differently.
| Part of the claim | How it is argued | How PI usually treats it |
|---|---|---|
| Negligent coordination | You did not review, challenge or chase the designers as a competent Principal Designer would | The centre of PI cover, with defence costs |
| A promise of compliance | Your appointment says you will “ensure” that the design complies | Wordings typically exclude contractual duties more onerous than the law would imply |
| Fire safety content | The gap was in the fire strategy or the fire stopping details | A fire safety endorsement may exclude or limit the claim although you designed nothing. Cover given back may be one aggregate sum, costs included |
| Delay and finance costs | The client claims months of lost programme | Usually treated as part of the client’s loss. A limited fire safety extension may exclude consequential loss |
| Fines and penalties | Passed on to you by the client or contractor | Excluded |
ARB’s guidance for architects accepts that restricted fire safety cover may be limited to direct losses, with consequential losses excluded (ARB, PII guidance). Fire safety exclusions explained
Bringing the other designers into the claim
A person liable for damage can recover a contribution from any other person liable for the same damage (Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978, section 1). That is how a Principal Designer passes a loss to the designer whose work did not comply.
In Lendlease v Aecom, the court held that a consultant with duties of review and coordination, not control, was not bound to oversee the others’ compliance ([2023] EWHC 2620 (TCC)). In Cooperative Group v John Allen Associates, an engineer who reasonably relied on a specialist contractor’s advice was held not to be negligent ([2010] EWHC 2300 (TCC)). Both turned on what the contracts said.
Some wordings exclude a claim where you have agreed to restrict your rights of recovery against another party. A low liability cap accepted from your own fire engineer or CDM adviser may weaken the contribution claim and the cover together. Freelancers and sub-consultants
The record that defends you
“All reasonable steps” is proved on paper. Insurers’ solicitors will ask for:
- The design responsibility matrix, showing who designed what and where the interfaces were.
- Minutes of design review meetings, with compliance on the agenda.
- The comments you issued to each designer, and evidence that each was closed or chased.
- Concerns that designers reported to you, and what you did with them.
- The principal contractor’s comments on compliance, and your response.
- The document you gave the client within 28 days of your appointment ending, explaining the arrangements you made (regulation 11M).
When the rejection or the letter arrives
- Notify the rejection, refusal or complaint as a circumstance when it arrives. Do not wait for a letter of claim.
- Do not tell the client you “should have picked it up”. It may read as an admission, and wordings commonly require insurers’ consent before any admission is made.
- Send us the appointment, the rejection reasons and the record above. We put the matter to insurers and ask them to appoint solicitors before you answer the client.
- Identify who wrote each criticised document, and have their appointments and insurance details to hand.
- Keep helping with the resubmission. A shorter delay is a smaller claim.
Has an application been rejected?
Send us the rejection and your appointment before you reply to the client, and we will put the matter to insurers properly.
Related: PI for principal designers · Claims support · Freelancers and sub-consultants